Court applies substantial evidence, not independent judgment, to a denied petition to end license probation early
The standard of review in an administrative mandate case depends on which decision is under challenge. In Bombardini v. Board of Psychology, the Third District applied substantial evidence, not independent judgment, to a psychologist’s denied petition to end probation early, and said independent judgment would have governed had she timely challenged the 2021 discipline order.
What happened in Bombardini v. Board of Psychology
The Board issued the appellant her license in 2011. In December 2019 it filed an accusation on two grounds. After a two-day hearing in 2020, at which she represented herself, the Board dismissed one cause and sustained the other. It imposed a stayed revocation and five years’ probation, effective April 23, 2021. She did not file a timely writ petition challenging that order. As an unpublished part of the opinion notes, she acknowledged in her opening brief that she “did not seek writ review of the 2021 disciplinary order.”
In July 2023 she petitioned for early termination of probation. The petitioner bears the burden of proof under Business and Professions Code section 2962, subdivision (d), “by clear and convincing evidence.” After a hearing in 2024, again without counsel, the Board denied the petition, finding she had not shown rehabilitation. That decision took effect May 23, 2024.
She then sought a writ of mandate in Sacramento County Superior Court, attacking both decisions. The trial court “denied the petition in its entirety, finding Bombardini’s attempt to challenge the 2021 decision was untimely and the 2024 decision was supported by substantial evidence.”
Which standard of review applies in an administrative mandate case?
The trial court’s choice of test was the published issue. As the opinion puts it, “Which test applies depends on whether the challenged decision ‘affects a fundamental vested right.’” If it does, the court exercises independent judgment. The independent judgment test also applies when an agency “imposes discipline on a professional licensee” short of revocation.
The appellant argued that the trial court should have used independent judgment. The Third District accepted the general rule that a licensee has a fundamental vested right to continue practicing, but it disagreed about the test because of what the 2024 decision actually did. She held “the right to practice her profession subject to the terms and conditions of her probation, and she sought to end those terms and conditions early.” The court then said:
This is more akin to applying for an unrestricted license than to disciplining an existing license.
The court called Flanzer v. Board of Dental Examiners (1990) 220 Cal.App.3d 1392 “instructive.” Flanzer involved a reinstatement petition and reasoned that “An applicant for reinstatement of a revoked license is in the same position as a person seeking a license in the first place.” The Third District added that courts are “relatively ill-equipped to determine whether an individual can safely resume the unrestricted practice” of a profession.
Can a licensing board avoid independent judgment review this way?
The appellant argued that substantial evidence review would let a board avoid independent review by labeling discipline as a stayed revocation with restrictions that prevent all practice. She also argued that the early termination hearing “was the only mechanism available to seek relief from restrictions that had made her license nonfunctional.”
The court’s answer to both arguments was timing. On the first, it said “Not so.” It explained:
Had Bombardini timely challenged the Board’s 2021 disciplinary order, the trial court would have applied the independent judgment test when reviewing that order.
On the second, it said “Again, not so.” It added: “She could have challenged the restrictions by timely appealing the 2021 disciplinary order, but she failed to do so.” That left only the 2024 order, which “was properly reviewed under the substantial evidence test.”
How the opinion calculated the writ deadline for a licensing board decision
The opinion describes the deadline under Government Code section 11523 as 30 days after the last day on which reconsideration can be ordered. The calculation itself is in an unpublished part of the opinion. The 2021 decision was mailed March 24, 2021, and took effect April 23, 2021. Thirty days from April 23 fell on a Sunday, and the court concluded that she “had to file a petition for writ of mandate by May 24, 2021.”
The standard also carried into the appeal. “An appellate court in a case not involving a fundamental vested right reviews the agency’s decision,” the court wrote, quoting Schafer v. City of Los Angeles (2015) 237 Cal.App.4th 1250, 1261, “rather than the trial court’s decision.” It looks at whether substantial evidence supports the agency’s findings, and “Questions of law, however, are reviewed de novo.” For another recent look at how much a substantial evidence standard matters on appeal, see Aviles v. Shenon.
The remaining challenges were resolved in Discussion parts II through IV, which are unpublished. Presiding Justice Earl wrote the opinion, joined by Justices Boulware Eurie and Feinberg. The disposition reads: “The judgment is affirmed, and the Board shall recover its costs on appeal.”
What this means in practice
I read this decision as a warning about sequence. The first disciplinary order was the one the court tied to independent judgment. A later petition to end probation was not, even though the licensee described the restrictions as making her license nonfunctional. A licensee weighing whether to live with a probation order is also deciding whether that order will ever get independent judgment review, and the time to make that decision is short. Writ review of an agency decision runs on its own statutory clock, not the one most people associate with an appeal.
Key takeaways
- The Third District held that a denied petition for early termination of professional-license probation was properly reviewed for substantial evidence, not independent judgment.
- The court reasoned that the petition was more akin to applying for an unrestricted license than to the discipline of an existing license, following the logic of Flanzer.
- The court said independent judgment would have applied to the 2021 disciplinary order had it been timely challenged, and that the restrictions could have been challenged that way.
- On appeal in a case not involving a fundamental vested right, the court reviews the agency's decision rather than the trial court's, with questions of law reviewed de novo.
Why cases like this one need an appellate lawyer early
The moment that decided whether the discipline order would get independent judgment review came in the spring of 2021, about three years before the hearing that produced the order on review. The discipline took effect in April 2021, and no timely writ petition followed. By the time the appellant reached the superior court, her challenge to the 2021 decision was untimely, and the only order left was one reviewed for substantial evidence. She also carried the burden of proof at the 2024 hearing by clear and convincing evidence.
That is what makes this process hard to navigate. The deadline does not run from an obvious date. It runs from the end of a reconsideration period, and missing it changes more than whether one order can be attacked. It affected the arguments available later.
An appellate lawyer calendars from the correct trigger, decides whether a writ is the right vehicle, identifies the standard of review before the record closes, and builds that record with review in mind. If a licensing board has ruled against you, talk to an appellate lawyer early, before a deadline runs or a record is lost.
What this post is not. This post is attorney advertising and general information about a court decision. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case turns on its own facts and record, and appellate deadlines are short and often jurisdictional — talk to appellate counsel about your case promptly.
Facing a ruling you may need to appeal or challenge by writ? Yisrael Gelb · yisrael@gelblawapc.com · (323) 632-6864