Eighth Circuit: bankruptcy sale appeal is moot when the buyer's good faith was never challenged below

Section 363(m) mootness ended this bankruptcy sale appeal before the merits were ever reached. In Riffenburg v. Rice (In re Roper), the Eighth Circuit held that a co-owner who objected to a trustee's sale, but never challenged the buyer's good faith in the bankruptcy court, could not keep his appeal alive once the sale closed without a stay.

What happened

Logan Riffenburg and his former wife, one of the Chapter 7 debtors, each held a one-half interest in property in Mountain View, Arkansas. After she filed for Chapter 7 relief in March 2023, the trustee moved under 11 U.S.C. § 363(b) to sell her half interest to Blue Sun Capital LLC. Riffenburg objected. The bankruptcy court overruled the objection, finding that the sale was “in good faith, for fair value, and in the best interest of all parties.”

That finding was about the trustee, not the buyer. The bankruptcy court did not mention the purchaser's good faith, and at oral argument the trustee conceded that no specific finding was made one way or the other. Riffenburg's objection had also targeted only the trustee's decision to sell.

Riffenburg appealed to the Bankruptcy Appellate Panel for the Eighth Circuit and asked the bankruptcy court for a stay pending appeal. The bankruptcy court denied it. Months later he renewed the stay motion before the BAP. A few weeks after that, with the motion still pending, the trustee moved to dismiss: the sale had been consummated, and the appeal was statutorily moot under § 363(m). A divided BAP agreed, dismissed the appeal, and denied the stay motion as moot. The Eighth Circuit, reviewing mootness de novo, affirmed in an opinion by Judge Gruender, joined by Judges Kelly and Kobes.

What is section 363(m) mootness?

Section 363(m) protects a completed sale to a good-faith purchaser from being undone on appeal unless the sale order was stayed. The Eighth Circuit calls this the “finality rule” and applies it when (1) an order approves a sale to a good-faith purchaser, (2) no party obtained a stay pending appeal, and (3) reversing the authorization would affect the validity of the sale. Here, the parties did not contest the second and third elements. The only question was the buyer's good faith.

Can you challenge the buyer's good faith for the first time on appeal?

No, under Eighth Circuit precedent. The court applied In re Rodriquez, 258 F.3d 757 (8th Cir. 2001), which held that an objector who did not challenge the purchaser's good faith in the bankruptcy court had not preserved the issue. Even without an express good-faith finding, dismissal follows if the objector never raised good faith below and the other requirements of § 363(m) are met. As the court put it:

“Under Rodriquez, Riffenburg’s failure to challenge Blue Sun Capital’s good faith in the bankruptcy court is dispositive.”

Riffenburg argued that the bankruptcy court made him present evidence of bad faith before the trustee presented any evidence, and that his objection to that sequence was overruled. The court was not persuaded: “a procedural objection to that order of operations is no substitute for a substantive objection to the purchaser’s good faith.” And the sequence did not stop him from offering evidence against the buyer's good faith, an opportunity the court said he never pursued.

Did MOAC Mall Holdings change the rule?

The dissenting BAP judge reasoned that the Supreme Court's decision in MOAC Mall Holdings LLC v. Transform Holdco LLC, 598 U.S. 288 (2023), which held § 363(m) is not jurisdictional, freed the courts to depart from Rodriquez. Riffenburg appeared to take up that view at oral argument, though not in his briefs. The Eighth Circuit disagreed. Whatever the jurisdictional label, it held, the core rule survives: a challenger to a trustee's § 363(b) sale “must challenge the purchaser’s good faith in the bankruptcy court.”

In a footnote, the panel wrote: “We are doubtful, however, that our holding in Rodriquez is faithful to the text of § 363(m).” It noted that the statute applies only to property purchased “in good faith,” that good faith is primarily a factual question for the bankruptcy court, and that the Third Circuit, in In re Abbotts Dairies of Penn., Inc., 788 F.2d 143 (3d Cir. 1986), requires a good-faith finding whenever a court authorizes a § 363(b)(1) sale. But the panel was bound by Rodriquez, and it observed that correcting the approach might not change the result here, because the record showed no real dispute about the buyer's good faith.

The disposition: “For the foregoing reasons, we affirm the BAP’s order dismissing Riffenburg’s appeal as statutorily moot.”

What this means in practice

A party who opposes a bankruptcy sale has two separate jobs before the appeal even starts. One is to contest the purchaser's good faith, with evidence, in the bankruptcy court, not just the trustee's business judgment. The other is to obtain a stay before the sale closes. Without a stay, and with good faith unchallenged below, the appeal in this case was dismissed as statutorily moot. For more on how stays pending appeal work in bankruptcy, see our note on a bankruptcy court's denial of a stay pending appeal.

Key takeaways

  • The Eighth Circuit held that a bankruptcy sale appeal was statutorily moot under section 363(m) because the objector never challenged the buyer's good faith in the bankruptcy court.
  • Under In re Rodriquez, that failure was dispositive even though the bankruptcy court made no specific finding on the purchaser's good faith.
  • A procedural objection to the order of presenting evidence did not substitute for a substantive challenge to the buyer's good faith.
  • The court held that MOAC Mall Holdings, which found section 363(m) non-jurisdictional, left the Rodriquez rule in place, while a footnote questioned that rule and noted the Third Circuit's contrary approach.

Why bankruptcy sale appeals like this one need an appellate lawyer

This appeal was effectively decided in the bankruptcy court. The objection in the bankruptcy court went to the trustee's decision to sell, not to the buyer's good faith, and under Eighth Circuit precedent that silence decided the case. The stay request was denied in the bankruptcy court, renewed at the BAP months later, and still pending when the trustee moved to dismiss because the sale had closed. Under circuit precedent, the court of appeals affirmed the dismissal.

Sale-order appeals turn on the record made at the sale hearing and on timing. An appellate lawyer involved at that stage looks ahead to what the appeal will need: a substantive challenge to the purchaser's good faith, supported by evidence and placed on the record; a prompt stay motion with a plan for seeking one at each level; and an appeal framed around the standard the reviewing court will apply. If you are opposing a bankruptcy sale or weighing an appeal of a sale order, talk to an appellate lawyer early, before the sale closes and the record is set.

What this post is not. This post is attorney advertising and general information about a court decision. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case turns on its own facts and record, and appellate deadlines are short and often jurisdictional — talk to appellate counsel about your case promptly.

Yisrael Gelb is the founder of Gelb Law APC, a California appellate and motion practice in Beverly Hills handling civil and criminal appeals, writs, and post-trial motions. About the firm · State Bar profile

Facing a ruling you may need to appeal or challenge by writ? Yisrael Gelb · yisrael@gelblawapc.com · (323) 632-6864

Start an intake Appeals and writs

← All notes · More on Appellate procedure