Writ petition over a blanket section 170.6 challenge was not moot, and the trial court must hold a bad-faith hearing
Writ petition mootness was the first fight in J.O. v. Superior Court, a published opinion from the Third District on remand from the California Supreme Court. County Counsel argued there was nothing left to decide. The Court of Appeal disagreed, treated County Counsel's unverified brief as a demurrer, and ordered the trial court to vacate a section 170.6 disqualification and hold a hearing on bad faith.
What happened in J.O. v. Superior Court
J.O. has been under a conservatorship in San Joaquin County since 2016. The county's Public Conservator, represented by County Counsel, served as conservator. Beginning in May 2024, County Counsel filed what the opinion calls "blanket" peremptory challenges under Code of Civil Procedure section 170.6 against the judge assigned to the department that heard most mental health cases: an estimated 325 of them in less than four months.
In August 2024, County Counsel filed a section 170.6 motion against that judge in J.O.'s case, and the court granted it by an order dated August 12, 2024. J.O. objected. Relying on Solberg v. Superior Court (1977) 19 Cal.3d 182, the trial court overruled the objection. J.O. petitioned the Court of Appeal for a writ of mandate, and a different panel summarily denied it. The Supreme Court granted review and decided J.O. v. Superior Court (2026) 19 Cal.5th 753, which overruled Solberg in part and sent the matter back to the Court of Appeal.
On remand, the Court of Appeal issued an order to show cause. County Counsel filed a "response" that argued only mootness. J.O. filed a traverse.
What happens when a party files a brief instead of a return to a writ petition?
A return to an order to show cause is a pleading, made by demurrer, by verified answer, or both. County Counsel's filing was neither. It was an unverified legal brief. The court was blunt: "This was not the proper procedure." It then explained the consequence: "In the absence of a true return, we will treat County Counsel's response as a demurrer," which meant accepting the petition's well-pleaded, verified allegations as true.
Was the writ petition moot?
County Counsel argued the petition was moot because the Public Conservator was no longer J.O.'s conservator after a successor was appointed in September 2024, and because the judge was no longer on the superior court. The court asked whether it could still grant effective relief, and it could. As the opinion put it, "J.O.'s conservatorship remains active, and the order granting County Counsel's section 170.6 motion remains in effect." That order still barred the judge from J.O.'s case. Vacating it would let J.O. contest the motion, and a ruling on bad faith would bear on whether future motions could be made.
The court added an alternative ground. Even if the case were moot, it would exercise its discretion to decide it: "Moreover, this case involves an issue of broad public interest that is likely to recur."
What the court ordered on the merits
The Supreme Court's decision set out a procedure for testing whether a section 170.6 motion is part of a bad-faith blanket policy. The party opposing the motion must first make a prima facie showing. If it does, a different judge holds a hearing, the party who filed the motion must offer a good-faith basis for it, and the court then decides whether bad faith has been proven.
J.O. had never made that argument. Before the remand, he had not alleged bad faith; he had argued that blanket section 170.6 motions always violate the separation of powers. So, the Court of Appeal observed, "no court has yet determined whether J.O. established a prima facie case of a bad faith blanket policy."
The remedy followed. The court directed a peremptory writ of mandate ordering the trial court to vacate its August 12, 2024 order granting the disqualification and to hold a hearing consistent with the Supreme Court's decision, at pages 782 to 785. Costs were denied in the interests of justice.
What this decision means in practice
Writ proceedings have their own pleading rules, and this opinion shows they are enforced. A respondent or real party who skips the verified return risks having the petition's facts taken as true. A mootness argument does not end a case when the challenged order remains in effect and the court can still grant effective relief, and a court may reach an important, recurring issue anyway. And the theory a party presents shapes the remedy: J.O. won a hearing, not a final ruling, because the bad-faith question had never been tried.
For how writ review fits alongside appeal, see our post on appealable versus writ-only orders and our writs practice page.
Key takeaways
- The Third District held the writ petition was not moot because the section 170.6 disqualification order remained in effect in an active conservatorship.
- The court said it would decide the case even if moot, because the issue is of broad public interest and likely to recur.
- Because County Counsel filed an unverified brief instead of a return, the court treated it as a demurrer and accepted the petition's well-pleaded, verified allegations as true.
- The court ordered the trial court to vacate the August 12, 2024 disqualification order and hold a bad-faith hearing under the Supreme Court's J.O. decision.
Why writ proceedings like this one need an appellate lawyer
This case took more than two years, a summary denial, a trip to the Supreme Court and a remand, and it is still not over. Along the way, the rules of writ practice shaped how the court proceeded. County Counsel answered an order to show cause with a brief instead of a verified return, and the court treated it as a demurrer, taking the petition's verified facts as true. The bad-faith question had never been presented, so the remedy available was a new hearing, not a final ruling.
An appellate lawyer works through those choices before they cost anything: whether an order is reviewed by appeal or by writ, how fast to move, what the petition must verify, how to answer an order to show cause, and which theory to present so the court can grant the relief actually needed. Mootness arguments, too, call for an answer grounded in the ongoing harm.
If an order in your case can only be challenged by writ, talk to an appellate lawyer early, while the record can still be built and the window is still open.
What this post is not. This post is attorney advertising and general information about a court decision. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case turns on its own facts and record, and appellate deadlines are short and often jurisdictional — talk to appellate counsel about your case promptly.
Facing a ruling you may need to appeal or challenge by writ? Yisrael Gelb · yisrael@gelblawapc.com · (323) 632-6864